As if I wasn't feeling shitty enough...

[ht_murray]

I just stumbled across a post by reading friends of friends lists in which someone talked about reading my 5.22 coda and about how beautiful and perfect it was but how she checked out and said, yeah, right at the end just because they were happy not living in the same room with each other any more.

Seriously, I like me a good wincest fic, but if you think they actually will never be able to live out of earshot of each other, that's just sad. Outside of universes where they really are the only two people in teh world, I think that's the saddest thing I've ever heard. There's no such thing as life in a bubble, people. Why would anyone want that for them?

And, ya know, yeah... I guess I really am a fuck up when it comes to SPN. Whatever.

Comments

[willow-fae-20.livejournal.com]

Oh...

I don't think I left feedback to your coda. *shame!face*

But I agree with you. With everything they've been through there is a definite divide. They need their space from each other.

I think they need some time apart to figure out who they are as individuals.

*hugs you close*

[mini-moue.livejournal.com]

Well, I don't want to spoil you, but I think your ending might be more prophetic that anyone else thinks... So yeah, I don't think you're watching it wrong, or getting it wrong. It's all very subjective and open to interpretation, anyway. I'm sure Kripke never imagined he'd write a show that coined the term "Wincest" and all its implications, but there you go.

I have to stop reading codas, because it's starting to get to me. It helped at first, but now... I just want it to be September and I want the boys back.

Failing that I'd settle for a decent pic of Jared and Jensen at Jensen's wedding. Preferably kissing, lol!

[willow-fae-20.livejournal.com]

I'd settle for a decent pic of Jared and Jensen at Jensen's wedding. Preferably kissing, lol!

THIS!!!!!

DO WANT!!!

[mini-moue.livejournal.com]

Hey, kisses aren't just for the bride! :-D

[maraceles.livejournal.com]

Oh god, I'm so sorry. I honest-to-god never thought you'd see my post to feel shitty about it, and like I said in that post, I thought your story was wonderful except for my admittedly tinhat-crazy love of the boys' codependency. Like you said, we don't have to like the same thing, and if you're happy about them being healthy and I'm happy about them being stupidly wrapped up in each other to the exclusion of everyone else, that's a personal choice only. It has nothing to do with your story--god, I'm so sorry. My post was more about me wondering about my own tinhat issues and less to do with your fic. I didn't post your name or the title because I didn't want to single you out, and I've failed at that miserably. I'm so, so sorry.

[pd-singer.livejournal.com]

Cookie?

[x5vale.livejournal.com]

*hugs you*

Honestly, wincest or not, I think the boys need to live on their own and find happiness somewhere else.